Nashua’s Alderman John Sullivan’s recent column to his ward gets one thing right: Nashua’s 9.5% tax increase, announced by the Mayor last Tuesday, is not the State’s fault. Nashua sets its own budget. Local leaders should own it.
But owning it means naming where the money actually goes, and that is where his column stops short. Voting no on the operating budget in June is the easy vote. The harder votes, the ones that will shape tax bills for the next twenty years, are the bond votes. On those, the Board of Aldermen has been nearly unanimous.
If we are going to talk about accountability, let’s talk about all of it.

The debt we keep voting for
The operating budget is only half the story. Every bond the Board approves is a mortgage on future tax bills: principal plus interest, paid by Nashua property owners for decades, long after the ribbon is cut and the vote is forgotten.
In February 2024, the City formed an ad hoc bond and debt committee to get this under control. It produced a sensible plan:
- Bond no more than $25 to $30 million in any year.
- Pay for projects under $2.5 to $3 million with cash, not borrowing.
The City has not stuck to that plan for a single year. Look at what came next:
- From March through December 2024, the Board authorized roughly $52.8 million in new bonds, nearly double the annual ceiling it had just set.
- In October 2024, the City sold $59.7 million in bonds. In October 2025, it sold another $44.5 million. Both blew through the $25 to $30 million cap.
- The rule against bonding small projects didn’t survive either. Since the committee formed, the City has borrowed for at least ten projects under $3 million, including a $600,000 police headquarters roof repair, a $500,000 hydroelectric upgrade, and $155,000 for recycling-area upgrades at the landfill.
A plan the Board ignores is not a plan. It is a press release.
Alderman Paula Johnson has been the strongest, most consistent voice in the chamber against excessive bonding. She has asked the questions the rest of the Board should be asking. Too often she has asked them alone.
Alderman Sullivan quotes Hemingway: “Gradually, then suddenly.” That is exactly how debt works. Each bond looks manageable on the night of the vote. Then one day the debt service line crowds out everything else in the budget, and taxpayers are told there is nothing left to cut. A no vote on the operating budget means little if the bonds that drive future budgets sail through.
Executive salaries on autopilot
Unaffiliated salaries in City Hall, the “executive” salaries, are rising at 8.5% to 15% a year. When the FY2027 budget was built, no one called for a freeze on those salaries. Not one alderman.
Residents are absorbing a 9.5% tax increase. The people at the top of City government are getting raises that match or beat it, year after year.
Alderman Sullivan warns that anyone who proposes a cut is met with fear mongering: “Are we going to cut police officers or firefighters or teachers?” He’s right. So let’s be clear: a freeze on executive salaries does not take a single officer off the street, a single firefighter off a truck, or a single teacher out of a classroom. It is the obvious place to start, and no one started there.
Risk Management: from $3.5 million to $10.7 million
In ten years under Mayor Donchess, the Risk Management budget has grown from about $3.5 million to more than $10.7 million. That is roughly triple.
That growth is out of step with what the City actually spends on property, casualty and liability coverage. Many expenses parked in Risk Management belong in the departments that generate them. Burying them in Risk hides the true cost of running those departments and makes the budget harder for the Board, and the public, to read.
Then it got worse. With Risk Management’s budget growing year after year and no one asking questions, Director Cummings dissolved the Human Resources Department and folded it under Risk. Along the way he eliminated key positions, including the staff responsible for employee benefits. Those functions are required by the City’s Revised Ordinances and Charter. The Board of Aldermen was never told.
Now the bill is coming due. Employees are filing complaints with the City and Department of Labor over benefits the City owes them and has underpaid. Litigation is climbing. A reorganization nobody approved is generating legal claims, and those claims land right back in the same Risk Management budget. Taxpayers pay twice: once for the unchecked growth, and again for the cleanup.
The Board should require a line-by-line accounting of what is in the Risk budget and move department costs back where they belong. It should also demand answers: Who authorized dismantling Human Resources? Which positions mandated by ordinance and Charter were eliminated? How many Department of Labor complaints and related claims are pending, and what will they cost?
A City Manager no one voted for
Nashua never voted for a City Manager. It got one anyway, and it pays him more than the Mayor.
The Mayor earns $149,000. Director Cummings, who is now running the City as a de facto City Manager, earns $182,000.
Nashua does not have a City Manager form of government. Creating one takes a Charter change, which means going before the Board of Aldermen and the voters. Neither happened. The Mayor made the switch on his own.
Here is why that matters. Under a properly chartered City Manager system, the manager answers to the elected Board, and the mayor becomes largely a ceremonial, goodwill figure, with a salary to match. Nashua now has the worst of both: a fully paid Mayor and a higher-paid manager who answers only to him. Taxpayers are paying for two chief executives and getting accountability from neither.
It gets better. The City’s own employee salary spreadsheet lists Cummings’s title as “Administrative Services Director and Chief Operating Officer.” The Board of Aldermen has never approved a Chief Operating Officer position. That is a title no one authorized, on a salary that outranks the Mayor’s, exercising powers the Charter never granted.
This is the same leadership that dissolved Human Resources without telling the Board. The risk Director Cummings has created for this city is coming home to roost, and taxpayers are the ones catching it.
The Board has the power to say so. So far it has refused to take a vote of no confidence in the Mayor’s choice of City leadership. It should. Director Cummings should be replaced, along with the small circle of loyalists the Mayor keeps in place with outsized salaries. Executive pay is supposed to buy competence and accountability. In Nashua, it is buying loyalty.
Legal: a blank check
Contracts to hire outside legal counsel do not have to come before the Finance Committee or the full Board of Aldermen. The result is predictable: spending on outside counsel is out of control, and no elected body is watching it.
In May 2024, the City gave the Board a litigation summary. It has not been seen since. More than two years is too long.
The Board should demand, now:
- An updated litigation summary of every open case.
- Total outside counsel spending by year, by firm and by matter.
- A rule that outside counsel contracts above a set dollar amount come before the Finance Committee.
The Board has the authority to ask pointed questions of the Legal Department and to insist on complete, candid answers from City leadership. It should use it.
A second arts center, 1.5 miles from the first
Right now, City staff, many of them from departments that are already short-staffed, are spending their time developing plans for another arts center in the Elm Street school auditorium.
About a mile and a half away sits the Nashua Center for the Arts, which is struggling to remain solvent. Building a second venue essentially next door would compete directly with the one taxpayers have already invested in and could badly compromise it.
This is not the time to expand. We have too much work to do and not enough people to do it. The Board should vote to shut this effort down now and put that staff time back where it is needed.
Question 2 sent a message to City Hall, too
Alderman Sullivan is right that the 58.7% vote on Question 2 sent a message, even though it fell short of the 60% threshold. Nashuans support public education and want spending kept in check.
That message was not only for the school district. It applies just as much to the City side of the budget: to bonding, to executive pay, to Risk Management, to Legal, and to new projects we cannot staff.
Questions, not slogans
Alderman Sullivan ends with “Where do we start? Questioning.” I agree. Here are the questions I’d like every alderman to answer on the record:
- Why has the Board not kept to its own bond spending plan since it was adopted in 2024?
- Will you vote against bonding any project under $3 million?
- Will you support a freeze on unaffiliated executive salaries in FY2028?
- Will you demand an itemized review of the Risk Management budget?
- Will you demand to know why Human Resources was dissolved and mandated benefits positions were eliminated without telling the Board?
- Will you vote to require that any City Manager or Chief Operating Officer role go through a Charter change, the Board and the voters, as the Charter requires?
- Will you take a vote of no confidence in the Mayor’s choice of City leadership?
- Will you require an updated litigation summary and Finance Committee review of outside counsel contracts?
- Will you vote to stop planning a second arts center?
There is another way. But it doesn’t start with a column. It starts with votes.