MACDONALD: Bad Bets

You can’t talk about affordability without addressing how bad an investment the public education system is. For two to three times the cost of non-government options, you get a kid with a diploma who’s shaking on his reading and may not be all that good at math.

The schools, unions, administrators, and most, if not all, of the Democratic Party insist that the problem is more money, and they hold the idea over parents’ heads as if they’ve taken their kids hostage. But if kids mattered, they’d teach them skills that empower them to teach themselves, instead of whatever is happening for 25-30k per kid per year and climbing.

Ian Underwood has rightly asked, or at least posited, the question of what exactly public education is for or about. What do you expect to get for that princely sum or any sum?

Day care is cheaper, and if you didn’t want to pay for it, you wouldn’t have to.

Many towns have sports options outside of schools, and if schools didn’t have them, every town probably would – paid for by the parents of kids who participate and donations, not taxpayers.

Lots of private music tutors out there who would compete for business if you wanted your kid to learn an instrument, to sing, dance, or whatever else happens at schools that isn’t teaching basic skills.

Voc-Techs exist and would pop up like weeds if learning hands-on trades weren’t being paid for by taxpayers by force.

Ian’s done the heavy lifting but he’s right. Schools do a lot of things, and none of them well, which is the kind of service you’d refuse to pay for under any other circumstance.

You certainly wouldn’t make a blank-check investment in that sort of future for your own kids, but you’re doing it for other people’s kids too.

It’s gotten so expensive that, as a taxpayer, you should ask what the general public good is. Bankrupting and driving people out of their homes.

You’re making bad bets, over and over, and getting swindled for more every hand. You’re betting not just money, but children’s minds, lives, and futures.

The system needs to change, but everyone just voted to make it exponentially worse.

It’s not hopeless.

Local elections are in the spring, and municipal elections in New Hampshire happen in the odd years. Find some good candidates now. Maybe a displaced House or Senate Republican.

Voters overwhelmingly supported the education tax cap to slow spending. We need serious people who will communicate the problem to taxpayers and outline real solutions.

Property taxes aren’t the problem; public education is. It swallows 70% of that bill, an investment in a bunch of crap under one roof that can’t seem to teach kids to read and do math.

They don’t need more money; they need to do less and therefore spend less, but serious people have to educate taxpayers and push back against administrators and the unions.

And if they threaten to strike, three words.

Education Management Organizations.

Private third-party vendors. They run it all and answer to you. The contract is binding, and if you don’t like the cost or the output, you can vote to replace them.

Better outcomes at probably a third of the cost or better per student per year, with accountability.

New Hampshire’s Constitution doesn’t even allow property taxes for public schools, but the paradigm hasn’t caught up to reality. You could wait, but I wouldn’t rely on the courts to help you.

Do it yourself.

Unless you can think of another way to solve all these problems and potentially cut your property tax bill by nearly two-thirds.

Talk about affordability.

Author

  • Steve is a long-time New Hampshire resident, an award-winning blogger, and a member of the Board of Directors of The 603 Alliance and the National Heritage Center for Constitutional Studies. He is the owner of Grok Media LLC and the Managing Editor, Executive Editor, assistant editor, Editor, content curator, and more (yes, there's more) at GraniteGrok.com. Steve is also a former board member of the Republican Liberty Caucus of New Hampshire, the Republican Volunteer Coalition, and has worked for or with many state and local campaigns and grassroots groups, and is a past contributor to the Franklin Center for Public Policy.

    View all posts
Share to...