Start at the Top
Seabrook taxpayers have repeatedly sent a message to their school district: They want their schools operated in a fiscally responsible manner. They sent that message once again when they voted in favor of a school tax cap in the last election.
On November 19, teachers stood before the school board, some in tears, pleading with board members not to eliminate their positions. They made a compelling case that these cuts should not be happening and suggested that the district consider other ways to reduce spending.
They were right.
How can teachers be among the first positions considered for elimination when the proposed budget includes adding a teacher coach? Coaches can serve a useful purpose, but when adding another position means eliminating classroom teachers, the district needs to reconsider its priorities. Several teachers made this very point during their comments to the board. Why create another position while eliminating teachers and potentially sacrificing worthwhile programs?
I would also urge school board members to take a closer look at the need for these coaching positions before adding them to the budget. Teachers have shared concerns with me in the past that these positions are not always necessary and can sometimes promote instructional practices that are not necessarily effective. For example, if a teacher recognizes that explicit, direct instruction is more effective for students, but a coach is pushing inquiry-based learning as the preferred approach, the coach may end up pressuring teachers to adopt methods that do not serve their students well.
I am not suggesting this is happening in Seabrook, but it is certainly something board members should consider before committing taxpayer dollars to another position. Seabrook already has several seasoned, experienced teachers in its classrooms. Often, the knowledge and professional expertise needed to support good instruction are already there. Why not make better use of that experience rather than adding another layer of personnel?
Others questioned administrative decisions and suggested that the district look at reducing administrative positions rather than putting the burden on classroom teachers.
The Associate Superintendent for Finance and Operations also proposed eliminating the Curriculum Coordinator position, pointing to declining enrollment as a reason the position is no longer necessary. I would take that argument a step further: Why did public schools decide they needed this additional layer of administration in the first place? Why is there still a Curriculum Coordinator at the SAU?
For generations, teachers selected and implemented curriculum without requiring a separate administrative position to oversee that process. Teachers are educated professionals. They should be trusted to identify and select quality instructional materials. Even homeschooling parents routinely research and select excellent curricula for their children. Why can’t we trust our classroom teachers to do the same?
Of course, declining enrollment sometimes makes reductions in teaching staff necessary. That is a reality school districts must address. But there is another question that deserves serious attention: Why are families leaving Seabrook schools in the first place?
That question has largely been missing from this budget discussion. What about the legal services that have been used to avoid reporting bullying cases to the New Hampshire Department of Education? Why was there no analysis of legal expenses used that could have been saved?
The school board voted against conducting exit interviews with parents who withdraw their children from the district. Why would a school board not want to understand why families are choosing to leave? What could be more important than identifying problems that may be driving families away?
When a district loses students, it loses more than enrollment numbers. It should be asking what went wrong, listening to parents, and making changes where necessary. Refusing to gather that information sends exactly the wrong message to the community.
The school boards throughout SAU 21 need to send a clear message to the Superintendent: Before asking students, teachers, and families to absorb the consequences of budget reductions, take a hard look at the administrative structure and the spending decisions being made at the top.
A tax cap should not automatically translate into fewer classroom teachers, fewer educational opportunities, or diminished academic programs. It should force administrators to examine their priorities, eliminate unnecessary expenses, and find efficiencies.
Teachers should not be the easiest target simply because their positions are visible in the budget.
