MACDONALD: NH Should Audit CVS

Part of the system that drives up drug prices is the coordination among insurers, pharmacy benefit managers (middlemen), and pharmacies. The fix is two-part. The public health industrial complex (PHIC) is a triad of cartels that control pricing – helped by the government, state and federal, that either rigs it in favor of the cartels or refuses to make the markets more competitive.

If medical and prescription coverage were like car insurance, you’d get funny, memorable ads, competition offering customizable plan options (so you only pay for what you want or need), and a wildly successful, open marketplace driving down costs.

TrumpRx drove down prices but at the end of the government gun. That’s not the best way to get it down, but under the current system, it was the best, fastest way. But a Blue Congress descended from the scam that is Obamacare isn’t going to do anything but join the cartel so it can get a piece of the action, and that means higher prices and, in many cases, depending on the government involvement, declining access and increased wait times.

As a reminder, Canada is solving that problem by using government doctors and counselors to convince people to choose medically assisted dying. Those would be the death panels y’all were warned about in 2009-2010 and beyond.

Breaking up monopolies and protecting laws (or creating them where they’re missing) that prevent the PHIC from blocking competition. TO that end, there’s been a lot of chatter about Pharmacy Benefit Managers. An in-between that adds an unnecessary layer of cost/control and bureaucracy between drug makers and pharmacies.

In 2025, Arkansas Governor Sarah Huckabee signed legislation prohibiting pharmacy benefit managers (“PBMs”) from owning or operating pharmacies. Shortly thereafter, CVS and Express Scripts (Cigna) found an unelected federal judge to issue an injunction blocking implementation of the law, which had been passed by a democratically elected legislature and signed by the elected governor. Arkansas’ attorney general subsequently commenced work on an appeal.

Shortly thereafter, the Tennessee legislature started debating a similar bill, which had bipartisan support in the Tennessee legislature.

Long story short, CVS spent buckets of money to lobby the legislation, but it had strong bipartisan support, and attempting to get a judge to sign an injunction didn’t exactly pan out.

In a major antitrust victory that didn’t even require the involvement of the Justice Department, CVS has just announced that it’s breaking itself into multiple companies by divorcing its healthcare provider, Aetna, and its pharmacy benefit manager, CVS Caremark, from its retail pharmacy operations.

Tennessee succeeded because the proposal to separate them came with receipts. It did a full audit of CVS in the state, and it was incredibly unflattering.

  • In a sample of 3,646 prescriptions, CVS Caremark paid a higher reimbursement rate to CVS pharmacies than to non-affiliated pharmacies for 18 percent of the sampled prescriptions.
  • Reimbursement appeals from independent pharmacies were often denied by CVS Caremark for “insufficient documentation,” even though the independent pharmacy had, in fact, provided all required documentation.
  • CVS Caremark was also not compliant with state regulations for handling reimbursement appeals from independent pharmacies.
  • CVS Caremark was not consistently paying dispensing fees to independent pharmacies as required by state law.
  • Despite a Tennessee law in 2021 that prohibited Pharmacy Benefit Managers from engaging in spread pricing, CVS Caremark continued to engage in this prohibited practice. (Spread pricing is where the price the PBM charges the healthcare provider exceeds the reimbursement it pays the pharmacy, with the PBM pocketing the difference.)

Breaking up PBMs has broad bipartisan support, and citing the situation in Arkansas and Tennessee as grounds for an audit might build voter interest for a larger debate about similar practices in other parts of so-called health care.

Anyone serious about cost and access would embrace that, but you’ll need Democrat voters on board because Democrat politicians are still married to an idea that is more about government control of care and therefore patients than encouraging choice to increase access and lower cost.

The Left’s propaganda machine will fight that harder than CVS fought its impending breakup, but it’s not impossible. Democrats won everywhere in New Hampshire on November 3rd but lost a majority of tax cap resolutions across the state.

School districts and teachers’ unions spent a lot of money, broke election laws, engaged in electioneering, and still lost a majority of towns to the tax cap.

You can do it if people get how much better it would be for them, their families, and their pocketbooks.

Click for early deals now; you save, and you help support GraniteGrok.com.

Author

  • Steve is a long-time New Hampshire resident, an award-winning blogger, and a member of the Board of Directors of The 603 Alliance and the National Heritage Center for Constitutional Studies. He is the owner of Grok Media LLC and the Managing Editor, Executive Editor, assistant editor, Editor, content curator, and more (yes, there's more) at GraniteGrok.com. Steve is also a former board member of the Republican Liberty Caucus of New Hampshire, the Republican Volunteer Coalition, and has worked for or with many state and local campaigns and grassroots groups, and is a past contributor to the Franklin Center for Public Policy.

    View all posts
Share to...