Stop START then re-START

ICBMNew Hampshire Senator Jeanne Shaheen chews up a large chunk of the Sunday Union Leader’s opinion page to sell us on president Obama’s START treaty with Russia.  Most of the words revolve around suggesting this will enhance security, that it is a good deal for America, and that there are a busload of experts, past and current military, former Secretaries of State, ex-presidents and sundry others who agree that this Treaty should be ratified.  But  a few things stand between taking this at face value and moving forward on her recommendation.

First, Mr. Obama, a man who has excelled at degrading his own country, and minimizing its global influence, wants it real bad.  Not a good sign.

Second, look at the context.  What would we say if this was George Bush, wasting political energy and government time and resources, to advance something like this when we should have all our attention on the failure of the debt commission to agree to its own recommendations?  Should we not still have all eyes and all hands dealing with a looming tax increase that could send the economy into a bigger tailspin just a few weeks from now?  What about the deficit? Where is the laser like focus? Why not job growth polices–other than using the extension of unemployment benefits for class warfare against opponents who just want it paid for from some dark corner of Obama’s multi-trillion dollar budget or one of his many slush funds.  Why START now?

Third, and this ties into the first, START is to strategic nuclear security what Obamacare was to Health care.  Its pursuit appears almost Pyrrhic, as if the victory must come regardless of the cost.  So this is not a strategic defense effort, it is just another feather in Obama’s agenda cap.  And with the brakes now being applied to his agenda come January 3rd, he is more obsessed with the Obama of history than the one responsible for national, and based on how they are selling it, Global security.

But like everything else that comes out of the administration or the drooling mouths of the party lap-dogs assigned to promote it, this is predicated on their standard template.  "We can’t just do nothing" and "Things could be worse."

If we search the landscape of the Obama Presidency however, neither of these ideas is compelling.  If we actually look at what Obama is willing to pass off as ‘doing something,’ it looks as if he has just bowed to another foreign leader, only this time over a nuclear weapons treaty.

Read more

Book Review: The Israel Test

Israel tEST 

Noted author John Wohlstetter, a national security and foreign policy expert with expertise in the Middle East and Israel, has written an excellent review of George Gilder’s new book, The Israel Test, for the American Spectator. We are pleased to share the piece with our readers…

Israel Inside 

The Israel Test
By George Gilder
(Richard Vigilante Books, 296 pages, $27.95)

This latest book from one of the planet’s intellectual titans of the past generation is one of his most important. Given George Gilder’s astonishing range and foresight — including family structure, welfare, the practical and moral case for enterprise capitalist wealth creation, the transformation of the computer and telecommunications industries — this is saying a lot.

What Gilder sets out to do in his poetic prose is show how Israel’s accelerating migration over the past twenty years from a socialist to a capitalist economy has transformed the Jewish state from an economic basket case to a powerhouse player in the world economy. Gilder then applies the implications of this metamorphosis to the prospects for finding a way to settle the Arab-Israeli conflict.

Israel has become such a huge driving force in computing and telecommunications that Gilder intellectually riffs off the "Intel Inside" logo that sits on the exterior case of countless millions of personal computers, and says that today’s Internet and computers should be labeled "Israel Inside." Now Israel is making major moves in biotechnology, including drugs for plants used in agriculture. Symbolic of the more agile Israeli economy, one CEO noted: "The process is faster for drugs because the plants don’t have lawyers."

Calling Israel the central front in the war dividing two global camps, Gilder begins his book by framing the divide:

The prime issue is not a global war of civilizations between the West and Islam or a split between Arabs and Jews….The real issue is between the rule of law and the rule of leveler egalitarianism, between creative excellence and covetous "fairness," between admiration of achievement versus envy and resentment of it….

The test can be summarized by a few questions: What is your attitude toward people who excel you in the creation of wealth or in other accomplishment? Do you aspire to that excellence, or do you seethe at it? Do you admire and celebrate exceptional achievement, or do you impugn it and seek to tear it down?

The Palestinians, needless to say, epitomize the wrong side of these juxtapositions, while Israel and America generally are on the right side. But now America must look toward Israel, whose Prime Minister exemplifies the right side of these divides, whereas the newly elected American President is on the wrong side — despite his having been richly rewarded by the society he now wishes to turn away from its historical celebration of private capitalist enterprise.

 

Read more

Dragon Soup Blog: Get yourself connected

Major Kirk

Major Kirk Luedeke

[Ed. note: It’s been a while, but we are pleased to welcome our milblogger, Major Kirk, back to the pages of GraniteGrok. See his prior dispatches from Iraq here…]

I just reached a small personal milestone- my 180th day home since the 4th Brigade of the 1st Infantry Division- Task Force Dragon- redeployed to Fort Riley from the Rashid District in Southern Baghdad. Life has been great for me, but hit me the other day that I really didn’t have a lot of visibility on what’s been going on in the old Iraqi neighborhoods since we departed in April.

It took a recent 60 Minutes segment by Lesley Stahl on CBS about the March and April battle for Sadr City- one that occurred out of our sector, but happened while we were still in Baghdad and in the process of handing over responsibility for Rashid to our counterparts- the 1st “Raider” Brigade of the 4th Infantry Division. The story is extremely well done and if you haven’t seen it, take a look (I’ve posted the link below).

The segment brought back a lot of memories for me. We saw some spillover in attacks directed at us by renegade Shia special groups criminals as a result of the fighting to our east across the Tigris. In fact, on the very night he arrived by Chinook helicopter my public affairs counterpart was standing next to my desk when a 107mm rocket screamed over the FOB Falcon wall and landed close to our brigade headquarters building. It exploded, violently spraying the structure with lethal shrapnel, shattering windows and shaking the foundation. Nobody was killed that night and there were only a few minor injuries, but the attack served as a wakeup call for all of us- we were short but our tour wasn’t over.

“Wasted away again in Mortaritaville,” I later deadpanned to my fellow PAO Dave (no, I wasn’t calm and collected enough to do it in the heat of the moment), and unfortunately for us, there would be other attacks to come at Falcon. A few days later, we would even get trapped in the Green Zone for several hours, compliments of some of the mortar and rocket attacks from Sadr City which forced the U.S. to take the action depicted on 60 Minutes.

When we left Iraq in late April, the battle had already started to move away from our collective consciousness, so seeing that story some six months later reminded me about how disconnected I’ve become from the events and life that I spent 430 days experiencing in 2007-08.

Being there, I was immersed in a never-ending news cycle. Even if my focus was on monitoring the various events and stories coming out of our area or Iraq/Afghanistan, I had a steady pulse on news from around the world as well. Never in my life have I felt more connected than I did in my job while deployed to Iraq.

So, fast forward to October 2008;

 

Read more

How to debate and frustrate infidels…

This is how Muslims try to frustrate us, the infidels… .

Lieberman: Lone voice in the Democratic wilderness…

Alone in the wilderness? (GG file photo) What more can be said about Joe Lieberman and his recent speech that hasn’t been already said by our friends over at the Contentions blog? Writes frequent MTNP radio guest Jennifer Rubin, Senator Joseph Lieberman spoke last night at the annual Commentary Fund dinner at New York’s University … Read more

Good points worth maintaining…

.  Sen. McCain in Wolfeboro; President Bush in Stratham. (GG file photos) When it comes to the mantra of John McCain being the third term of President Bush, beyond the obvious lack of proof that McCain and Bush march lockstep in all matters, there are some positive points about the president that are worth emulating … Read more

Guest Blog: “Your today has been paid for by those who gave up their tomorrows.”

ROTC vandalism in NC in 2006 Are You Sleeping? by Debbie Lee Military helicopters vandalized in Pennsylvania, recruiting offices attacked in over 42 cities, funding denied for our troops, Code Pink sending 600,00.00 to the enemy. How many more treasonous acts need to occur before we stand up and say enough is enough? Spineless, gutless, Politicians … Read more

Notable Quote: Machiavelli

Saturday was Machiavelli’s birthday (May 3rd, 1469). While much reviled by some as a ruthless political animal, there are many that believe him to be the master of political observation and strategy– based on the realities of human nature as it exists, not fanciful utopian wishes. His best known work, The Prince, is a book about the attainment and preservation … Read more

Dragon Soup: Front page of USA Today reports: 75% of Baghdad Secure

Colonel Ricky Gibbs, commander of the 4th Infantry Brigade Combat Team, 1st Infantry Division
Colonel Ricky Gibbs, commander of the 4th Infantry Brigade Combat Team, 1st Infantry Division, talks to Iraqi children in the Masafee neighborhood of East Rashid, Baghdad during a recent visit there. (U.S. Army photo by Maj. Kirk Luedeke, 4IBCT Public Affairs)

 
Kudos to USA Today reporter Jim Michaels, whose front page story in the Jan. 18-20 edition of the paper reports that 75% of Baghdad’s neighborhoods are secure as opposed to just 8% exactly one year earlier.
.
This is an important story because it quantifies the progress that has been gaining momentum in mainstream media reporting since General David Petraeus issued his Iraq War progress report to the House and Senate back in September.
.
My boss, Colonel Ricky Gibbs, commander of the 4th Infantry Brigade Combat Team, 1st Infantry Division stationed here in Southern Baghdad, was interviewed for the story and I sat in on the telephonic interview he conducted with Michaels. Here are some points that didn’t make the final cut in the story, but provide further context for Michaels’ fair and accurate reporting:

Read more

Days of Infamy. What a difference sixty six years makes…

Carrier Shokaku
Planes of second wave ready for takeoff on carrier Shokaku
.
“On the morning of December 7, 1941, that Fleet’s planes bombed all the US military air bases on the island (the biggest was the US Army air base at Hickam Field), and the ships anchored at Pearl, including ‘Battleship Row’. Nearly every plane on the ground was destroyed; only a few fighters got airborne and opposed the attacking planes. Twelve battleships and other ships either were sunk or damaged, 188 aircraft were destroyed, and 2,403 Americans lost their lives. The battleship USS Arizona exploded and sank with a loss of over 1,100 men, nearly half of the American dead.”
The next day, President Roosevelt addressed Congress. [These quotes come directly from the noted speeches as found in Volume Two of the series "This is America My Country", 1952.]
“Yesterday, December 7, 1941- a date which will live in infamy- the United States of America was suddenly and deliberately attacked by naval and air forces of the Empire of Japan.”
He went on to describe the job at hand:
“As Commander-in-Chief of the Army and Navy I have directed that all measures be taken for our defense.”
Roosevelt then rightly predicted,
“Always will our whole nation remember the character of the onslaught against us. No matter how long it may take us to overcome this premeditated invasion, the American people in their righteous might will win through to absolute victory.”
In his December 9th radio address to the Nation President Roosevelt said,
.

Read more

History recommends “prudent rulers” and “pre-emptive” war. Or else…

machiavelliIran hostages
.
Bush the conqueror
.
MaldivesCulture writes in this post from 2003
Niccolo Machiavelli was an Italian who died 1527 at the age of 58. He was a famous political theorist who advocated the principle of realpolitic – politics in its real sense, and how a ruler should rule a country.
.
Realpolitic might be described as the dirty side of politics. Machiavelli believed that human beings are by nature more likely to do evil things than good. Human beings are ungrateful, selfish, violent, and anti-social and have an instinct of wickedness that is always dominant in their behaviour.
I was re-reading some portions of The Prince by Machiavelli, which I like to do from time to time, and came across this passage that really sums up our present situation. By not taking care of the Islamic problem when it manifested itself in the 1979 hostage crisis, we instead find ourselves in a much worse situation today, with Iran on the verge of obtaining nuclear weapons. Discussing the relationship between Rome, Greece, and the surrounding territories, Machiavelli writes:
[T]he Romans did what all wise rulers must: cope not only with present troubles but also with ones likely to rise in future, and assiduously forestall them. When trouble is sensed well in advance it can easily be remedied; if you wait for it to show itself any medicine will be too late because the disease will have become incurable.
Keep in mind that at the time, Rome was the dominating power throughout the civilized world, much as, whether we want to admit it or not, America is today. If you believe that this is OK because ours is the best civilization, as I do, then you know that the same maxims of self defense apply to us as they did to the Romans and should be employed. In a world of would-be destroyers, sometimes action is necessary. Machiavelli continues:
As the doctors say of a wasting disease, to start with it is easy to cure but difficult to diagnose; after a time, unless it has been diagnosed and treated at the outset, it becomes easy to diagnose but difficult to cure. So it is in politics. Political disorders can be quickly healed if they are seen well in advance (and only a prudent ruler has such foresight); when, for lack of a diagnosis, they are allowed to grow in such a way that everyone can recognize them, remedies are too late.
The question we face is whether at present, we are treating the "disease" that is Islamicism at the outset, or near the end. Should we have stamped out the problem in 1979? With over a billion Muslims and growing, all susceptible to the radicalized strain of the Islamo-fascists, are we too late? Maybe not. Again, from The Prince:

Read more

Sunday Essay: Don’t they get it? Sadly, they probably do

.
hillary.saigon withdrawal.Obama
Kucinich.Biden.Richardson.Dodd.
.
The introduction to the Roger Ames translation of “The Art of Warfare” tells us about the ancient Chinese writings dating back to 403 BC:
“The Sun-Tzu, or ‘Master Sun,’ is the longest existing and most widely studied military classic in human history.”
With a period of continuous warfare lasting hundreds of years, Ames writes that,
“Scores of small, semiautonomous states had joined in an ongoing war of survival, leaving in its wake only the dozen or so ‘central states’ (chung-kuo) from which present day ‘China’ takes its actual Chinese-language name. By the fifth century B.C., it had become clear to all contenders that the only alternative to winning was to perish.”
That was the reality at the time when the famous texts were first written. They have been studied and put into practice in some form or other ever since.
.
The military strategies and philosophy put forth by Sun-Tzu are considered equally helpful to expansive states (superpower) as well as lesser forces. In modern times, however, it appears that the weaker sides in conflicts have been more adept at employing its tenets. It has been widely maintained that communist North Vietnamese General Vo Nguyen Giap was well-versed in “The Art of Warfare”. Many claim it was in fact, THE blueprint for plans leading to America’s ultimate withdrawal from Viet Nam, allowing the communist north to defeat the democratic south.
.
In today’s world of weapons of mass destruction coupled with the brewing global- war between the West and Islamic-fascism, we see once again that civilization is reaching a tipping point where “the only alternative to winning is to perish.” Make no mistake about it- our enemy’s intent is to win, or die in the attempt. Back in 1996, Osama Bin Laden wrote in his “Declaration of War Against The Americans”:

Read more

Today marks the start of an important week… Part I

Japanese formally surrender ….retreat from saigon
   The choice:                this…                                                            or this.
.
I have made much through the last few years about President Bush’s less than stellar job he’s put in as the wartime leader of our Nation. Democratic nations, history tells us, cannot sustain and win wars without the popular support of their peoples. I don’t particularly question WHAT we are doing in the many fronts of the new world war, but rather, the fact that ordinary people haven’t been brought along. This leaves us in a position where uninformed voters, thoroughly propagandized by the President’s political enemies, will choose new leaders incorrectly, thus leading us towards possible defeat in the place of victory. That being said, there comes a time where, with or without proper leadership, each of us, as American citizens, must look at the facts and judge for ourselves what is the right thing to do.
.
This week, we find ourselves at one of those moments. After a general shift in strategy and tactics newly implemented in the Iraqi front in the new world war, we will be given the first major "official" assesment of the results. Despite the general acknowledgment that the situation is turning around, President Bush’s detractors in the Democratic Party seem hell-bent on denying at all costs any positive news. Already, before we even get General Petraeus’ report, Democrats like Chuckie Schumer and others are trying to spin whatever we hear as nothing more than more Bush lies. And why not? After having based their entire political plans around their hoped-for loss in Iraq, anything that says something to the contrary just cannot be allowed.
.
With a president seemingly unable to get his side of the story out to the country at large, and a political party intent on destroying him and his fellow Republicans (and quite possibly our Nation’s future) in its quest to attain power through the use of lies and heated emotion, it is up to each and every one of us to judge for ourselves. Listen to the evidence firsthand. Don’t allow "spin" to tell you what you should think and "feel."
.
Here is a letter given Friday to the troops in Iraq by their leader, General David Petraeus. It is the prelude to what we will be hearing this week. Rather than let John Edwards or Hillary Clinton or Harry Reid tell you the situation, listen instead to the guy who’s on the ground trying to get the thing finished and won…

07 September 2007

Soldiers, Sailors, Airmen, Marines, Coast Guardsmen, and Civilians of Multi-National Force-Iraq:

We are now over two-and-a-half months into the surge of offensive operations made possible by the surge of forces, and I want to share with you my view of how I think we’re doing. This letter is a bit longer than previous ones, since I feel you deserve a detailed description of what I believe we have — and have not — accomplished, as Ambassador Crocker and I finalize the assessment we will provide shortly to Congress.

Up front, my sense is that we have achieved tactical momentum and wrested the initiative from our enemies in a number of areas of Iraq. The result has been progress in the security arena, although it has, as you know, been uneven. Additionally, as you all appreciate very well, innumerable tasks remain and much hard work lies ahead. We are, in short, a long way from the goal line, but we do have the ball and we are driving down the field.

Read more

Hey Dennis Kucinich, today is YOUR day!

On this date, August 27th, in 1928, the treaty making war "illegal" was signed: The Kellogg-Briand Pact.

That’s right, that treaty, still considered to be in effect on this very day, officially outlaws war.

The website http://www.u-s-history.com/pages/h1485.html tells us

Relations between the United States and France had cooled in the aftermath of World War I. A number of issues had driven the former allies apart, including:

  • residual tensions from hard bargaining and perceived double-dealing at Versailles;
  • the continuing effort of the U.S. to collect the full amount of war debts incurred by hard-pressed France;
  • the embarrassment felt by France because of being assigned a lesser naval role at the Washington Conference (1921);
  • the recent failure, regretted by both nations, of the Geneva Conference (1927).
An effort was made by French foreign minister Aristide Briand to warm-up relations between the two former allies. Columbia University professor James T. Shotwell met with Briand in France and suggested that a bilateral treaty be negotiated that would outlaw war between the two nations. Briand seized this idea and presented it in an open letter to the American people.

The Coolidge government, at least initially, was not interested in having its hand forced in diplomatic matters and offered no response. A few weeks later, Columbia President Nicholas Murray Butler sounded the same theme in a letter published in The New York Times. The press in New York and elsewhere began a drumbeat calling for the “outlawry of war.”

Even back then, the news media and their ideological comrades in acedemia espoused silly, utopian notions that failed in the face of reality.

.
The u-s-history.com entry continues:

Read more

VLog– Question for McCain: Was Truman right?

John McCain meets the press in Wolfeboro, NH . As Skip has noted in his previous postings, we got to ask Senator McCain several questions following Friday’s "town hall" style campaign event at the Wright Museum. Given that we were in a World War II museum, and it is the 62nd anniversary of Truman’s decision to … Read more

Doing The Right Thing!

This is from a grandmother of a soldier serving in Iraq. Again, WAKE UP! America. This gal gets it, what’s wrong with you?

"Lord help our military…..This important article only proves what I have been saying. Our military’s biggest challenge is our politicians, not the war in Iraq. After giving themselves a large raise, gone on a months break, our troops armor is postponed for lack of funds. Where is the decency, or common sense in our government. Where is the outrage, and where is the media. Thank you Oliver North for caring. Dolly"

Dolly, you hit the nail on the head; i.e., there is no common sense being used by the demoractic controlled House and Senate of the United States of America. They want us to lose the war in Iraq, SO they’ll get re-elected. They have absolutely no vested interest in winning the war because they’ll be "wrong" and our President will be "right."  They’ll have egg on their faces and their self-esteem will suffer. They won’t be able to maintain their illusion of "we support the troops" and we ended the war because we speak for the American people and we know what’s best for America!

In case some of you people who insist on maintaining your deep state of denial out there need another hit on the head with the proverbial nail, here it is stated another way: We win the war in Iraq, the democrats are out of office. America loves President Bush instead of continuing to blame him and hate him for anything and everything. 

Here’s what the dems and the left-wing very old AND GETTING OLDER BY THE MINUTE media tells you and some of you completely ignorant Americans keep buying into it: The bridge in Minnesota collapsed, it’s President Bush’s fault. A tornado hit parts of the Ohio valley yesterday, it’s President Bush’s fault! Stupid people who got in over their head by getting low adjustable rate mortgages and now can’t afford them, it’s President Bush’s fault. Oh yeah, but we still want him to bail us out because we’re "victims" and have a "victim’s mentality, and we don’t want to be responsible or accountable for our own poor choices. Again, it’s President Bush’s fault.

These are all about as logical as: I broke a nail this morning and it’s President Bush’s fault.

Read more

Happy A-Bomb Week!

hiroshima
.
.
This is a rerun of something I like to publish annually during this week of August:
.
This week’s events of 62 years ago should not go unnoticed, or unappreciated. On August 6th, 1945 and again on August 9th, the United States dropped atomic bombs on Japan. Prior to that, on July 26, 1945, the Allies, in setting the conditions for ending a war that they did not start, called for the unconditional surrender of the Japanese and their military forces. Absolutely fanatical, with a declared fight to the death, the Japanese refused. Years of war, and still, they would not stop. Then the bomb fell.
.
President Harry S. Truman, sworn to protect and uphold the Constitution and expected to do all possible to “provide for the common defense”, made the decision. The first atomic bomb fell on Hiroshima, Japan August 6th, 1945. In his address to the nation, Truman spoke:
“Sixteen hours ago an American airplane dropped one bomb on Hiroshima, an important Japanese Army base. That bomb had more power than 20,000 tons of TNT.”
.
“The Japanese began the war from the air at Pearl Harbor. They have been repaid manyfold. And the end is not yet.”
The bomb used in the attack, announced the President was
“an atomic bomb. It is a harnessing of the basic power of the universe. The force from which the sun draws its power has been loosed against those who brought war to the Far East.”
.
Imagine yourself to be alive at that time. Perhaps you were. I cannot believe that every American, to a person, would not have wanted their leaders to do EVERYTHING possible to end the war, and to make everybody safe. Imagine yourself a young GI at the time- twenty-something years old, training for yet more warfare. Having survived through to the end of the war in Europe, would you ultimately join those less fortunate, living only to see a later death in the Japanese theater? Imagine a young wife back in America- perhaps with children. What will happen to her husband? Where is their father? Imagine a mother. What will happen to her son? What of America’s brave soldiers? Will any survive the coming battles in the Pacific? Will they die storming through hellfire on the beach on some Pacific island, facing an enemy that will not stop? When will this war end? Then the first bomb fell.
.
The Commander-in Chief, again, from his speech to the Nation (and the World):

Read more

Is it, or isn’t it? We’ll probably never really know… [UPDATE #2]

. As I flipped through the cable news channels for one last time before I was going to turn the TV off for the night, a story caught my attention on CNN. It was being reported that a suspicious vehicle had been stopped for what was described as a "routine" traffic violation. In the vehicle, … Read more

Hey Harry, remember this?

.
This is a letter from a retired military person (hero) and current member of the Pease Greeters group here in NH, written in response to Sen Harry Reid’s "the war is lost" remark. He provides a good history lesson that, if not learned, we are doomed to repeat. We must NOT allow that to happen…
.
Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid Said the Iraq War is “Lost”
We, the members of the Portsmouth N.H. Air Terminal Greeters, thank and honor all our forces as they go to or return from Iraq. When we speak to those who are doing the fighting, we never hear a trace of the pessimism as that expressed by Senator Harry Reid.
.
As a soldier with two tours of duty in Vietnam, I am disgusted that there are those in our governmental leadership that are attempting to repeat the disastrous mistakes of 1968. 
.
In January 1968 the Communist Forces launched their surprise Tet Offensive throughout Vietnam.  The American T V coverage of the offensive made the war seem hopeless, wasteful, and most likely lost.  Walter Cronkite, viewing the battle from Saigon declared the war, “un-winnable”.  Later our soldiers’ actions were characterized as, “immoral”.
.
Published memoirs, documents, and interviews made public by Hanoi, reveal an entirely different assessment of offensive. The elites in media and universities have access to all these documents.  However, they have ignored even their very existence. The fact that we came close to winning the war in1968 conflicted with their left wing mind set.  
.
The losses suffered by the Communist’s Forces in their Tet Offensive of 1968 were so devastating, that Hanoi was at the brink of suing for piece. Their only hope for victory lay in what they saw on American T V.  They could not win on the battle field. However, using their ideological friends in the U S they resolved to erode our political will on our city streets. This resulted in seven more years of war, 30,000 more U S deaths and defeat.

Read more

Another remake of an old story…

According to Wikipedia, on the act of treason, The United States Code at 18 U.S.C. § 2381 states "whoever, owing allegiance to the United States, levies war against them or adheres to their enemies, giving them aid and comfort within the United States or elsewhere, is guilty of treason and shall suffer death, or shall … Read more

Share to...