OPINION: Kittery Hit the Brakes. Is Portsmouth Paying Attention?

When Kittery recently announced that it had effectively run out of available water capacity for new hookups, many residents on both sides of the Piscataqua were stunned.

Water?

In New England?

How could a coastal community surrounded by rivers, streams, reservoirs, and the Atlantic Ocean suddenly find itself unable to support additional growth?

The answer is simple. Water availability is not determined by what appears on a map. It is determined by how much treated drinking water a community can reliably produce every day during droughts, maintenance outages, equipment failures, and periods of peak demand.

Once a system approaches its limits, consequences arrive quickly. Housing projects slow or stop. Commercial expansion becomes more difficult. Economic growth is constrained. Communities suddenly find themselves considering expensive solutions such as new reservoirs, additional treatment facilities, distant pipelines, or even desalination plants.

Kittery’s experience raises an obvious question.

Could Portsmouth someday face the same challenge?

The Number Everyone Should Know

According to Portsmouth’s most recent planning information, the regional water system has a safe yield of approximately 5.87 million gallons per day. The system serves not only Portsmouth but also Pease Tradeport and several neighboring communities.

Average daily demand reportedly reached approximately 4.1 million gallons per day in 2025, placing the system at roughly 70 percent of safe-yield capacity.

Seventy percent may sound comfortably below the red line. Utility planners often view it differently.

It is not a crisis threshold.

It is a planning threshold.

At that point, communities should begin evaluating future demand, conservation opportunities, infrastructure investments, and potential additional water sources before a problem develops.

Many communities make the mistake of treating remaining capacity as an endless reserve. It is not. Growth, weather events, regulatory changes, and operational challenges can consume available capacity far faster than expected.

The 3,000-Unit Question

Since 2020, approximately 3,000 housing units have been approved but are not yet connected to the water system. Estimates suggest those units could eventually require approximately 375,000 additional gallons per day.

If those projections are accurate, average demand could rise from roughly 70 percent of capacity to approximately 76 percent of safe yield.

That figure should not create panic.

It should attract attention.

Approved projects represent only known demand. They do not account for future development proposals, redevelopment pressure, growth in neighboring communities, infrastructure failures, drought conditions, or future regulatory requirements.

Portsmouth Doesn’t Just Serve Portsmouth

One of the most overlooked aspects of the discussion is that Portsmouth’s water system extends beyond city limits.

The regional network serves Portsmouth, Pease Tradeport, Newington, New Castle, Greenland, and portions of Rye and Madbury. Portsmouth supplies all public water for New Castle and portions of several neighboring communities.

As a result, future growth throughout the region affects Portsmouth’s water equation. Housing developments, apartment projects, commercial expansions, public facilities, and economic growth all add demand to the same shared system.

The challenge is not what happens next year.

The challenge is understanding what demand will look like ten or twenty years from now.

The Plan That Expired

Perhaps the most troubling aspect of the discussion is not today’s water demand.

It is the absence of an updated roadmap.

According to city records and public discussions, Portsmouth’s 2013 Water Master Plan expired in 2023 and was not renewed. A motion to extend or reauthorize the plan was defeated after opposition led by City Councilor Kate Cook leaving the city without an updated planning framework.

A water master plan is not merely another government document. Its purpose is to force communities to ask difficult questions before a crisis develops.

How much growth is expected?

How much water will that growth require?

Which sources are vulnerable?

What investments should begin now rather than later?

Those questions become increasingly important as utilization rates move beyond 70 percent and continue upward.

Residents may disagree about development policy, but everyone should agree that planning matters.

Water Quality Matters Too

Safe yield is not simply a question of quantity.

If ocean water were drinkable without treatment, coastal communities would have an almost unlimited supply. Instead, municipalities must deliver water that meets stringent health and environmental standards.

Portsmouth routinely tests for contaminants including lead, copper, arsenic, bacteria, nitrates, industrial pollutants, and PFAS compounds. Managing those contaminants requires continuing investments in treatment and monitoring.

Water managers may also limit withdrawals from certain wells to preserve quality. As a result, the practical safe yield of a source can be lower than its maximum pumping capacity.

Water quality and water quantity cannot be separated.

Growth Versus Capacity

This is where the political debate begins.

One side argues Portsmouth desperately needs additional housing. The other argues infrastructure should determine the pace of growth.

Both concerns are legitimate.

Housing shortages are real.

Water constraints are real.

The answer is not a building moratorium, nor is it unlimited development. The answer is disciplined planning based on realistic projections.

If future demand may approach system limits, officials should say so. If conservation measures can buy time, implement them. If additional sources or source-water protections are needed, begin studying them now while options remain affordable.

What Portsmouth should avoid is the mistake that appears to have caught Kittery by surprise.

Waiting until the last available gallon has already been committed is not a strategy.

It is a countdown.

The Question City Hall Should Answer

The most important question is not whether Portsmouth has enough water today.

It almost certainly does.

The real question is this:

What is projected demand in 2030, 2035, and 2040, and how does that compare with available safe yield?

If those projections already exist, they should be shared publicly.

If they do not, producing them should become a priority.

Kittery’s experience offers a cautionary tale from just across the river. Communities rarely run out of water overnight. Long before they run out of water, they run out of planning first.

The Shoals Ledger

Authors’ and Speakers’ opinions are their own and may not represent those of Grok Media, LLC, GraniteGrok.com, its sponsors, readers, authors, or advertisers.

Disagree, agree, Got Something to say? We Want to Hear It. Comment or submit Op-Eds to steve@granitegrok.com

Author

Share to...