Iterated Games and Hierarchies of Preference
It will come as no shock to my readers that the election has left us in a difficult position. The first thing to understand is that difficult does not equal defeat. This is an opportunity to take a lesson from the Army Rangers: always be improving your fighting position. We may not have a lot of offense to enact at present, but we certainly have a lot to do to prepare to be successful for our next offensive opportunity while we defend.

It would seemingly go without saying that our goal and strategic win condition is victory. Of course, that seems quite simple. However, the next strategic moves won’t necessarily seem so obvious. They won’t seem so obvious because you probably aren’t used to thinking about these things in terms of iterated games and preference hierarchies. In other words, elections are not one-and-done, but rather a match that sets the stage for the next match, and then again thereafter, at least until there are no more elections.
Preference hierarchies don’t have to be complicated either. What do we want? Victory! When do we want it? Now! Clearly, victory now is the first preference. But if victory is not achievable now, victory later is my second preference. That’s the simple version, anyway, but it gives you what you need to understand what will follow with my analysis.
We will, here, examine a situation wherein an election has rendered a legislature Left-controlled and the executive ostensibly Right-controlled, through with an uncertain ally at the helm. Such is the case with any establishment GOP politician occupying the corner office: whether they cave on the “culture war” issues is always a question mark. Governor Sununu, after all, gave us DEI in law and solidified the civil-rights supremacy regime that nearly consolidated its control over the bureaucracy, and over your Constitutional rights.
Loads of Early Black Friday Deals – The ‘Grok is an Amazon Affiliate

Now, working on an extension of the above’s mantra, we do in fact want victory now. What does that look like? That looks like the corner office vetoing not just every tax and spending increase, but more importantly every “culture war” issue. (I still loathe that term that means to diminish everything from parental rights to the mutilation of children. Properly understood, the “culture war” is nothing less than an earnest resistance to Communist revolution that would make our founders proud – they certainly didn’t talk about America as an economic zone.)
In fact, the tax-and-spend issues are far less pressing than the cultural revolution. If the Democrats want to spend, and they have to votes to do so, they should at least be forced to pay for that spending with commensurate tax increases now so that later, when the GOP gets another chance at offense, they don’t have to deal with a deficit and a credit card bill that will force them to be the ones that raise taxes while the duplicitous liars across the aisle point to us and scream “taxman!”
Consider what motivates you more for a moment… is it a marginal tax increase or the institution of laws and policy that force you to send your child to a public school (because they will try to outlaw homeschool) where they will be encouraged by Mx. Tranny to change their name and take hormones and then, when you decline to go along, they sick DCYF on you, take your child into state custody, and send you to jail for hate speech? I mean, we quite literally just gave you all the authority to limit your marginal tax increases in school budgets in this election, and nearly half of you didn’t vote for it. Clearly, threatening your family, your children, and your basic freedoms scores higher in priority.
This is also true of people broadly as our nation undergoes a kind of Balkanization, with people moving to locales that better represent their ideological persuasion. It is not foremost the marginal tax rates that initiate things as dramatic as packing up your family and moving across state lines. It’s ideology. It’s liberty versus tyranny. It’s woke versus free. We can’t have victories that lend towards the relocation of substantial numbers of adversary into our political jurisdiction. Further, the policies of the Left are invariably cutthroat, and are maximally geared towards consolidation of power. That’s true from breaking election security norms to morphing our education system towards Marxist indoctrination. We must incentivize those who love opportunity and freedom and disincentivize those who seek undue control and privilege from moving here.
Finally, tax increases were baked into this election outcome because spending increases were baked in. When it comes to spending money there’s lots that the Left and the center-right can agree on, and it’s all getting funded. Nothing we can do about that, so take that hit now and straighten your back so we can fight for what we might actually accomplish.
In order to statistically maximize our chances of “victory now,” again, here, just vetoing all the Left cultural revolution issues, we should heap praise on positive actions and maintain a hard line on what happens if that does not happen. The move is to min/max on incentives that give the governor maximum cover and praise for taking on the moral and cultural issues. That means a clean slate. It doesn’t, right now, matter that the governor has not been much of an ally on the culture war issues. It does not matter that the corner office has been more reliably Democrat than Republican in the culture war. This is a new field in the iterated game, so we start from zero.
However, we don’t stay at zero. We must look again to our short lesson on hierarchy of preference. In this case, like in the example, the preference is victory now, and the second preference is victory later. If victory now proves unachievable, for instance, in the allowing of major culture war issues such as the mutilation of children or sicking of DCYF on Right-wing or Christian families to occur by allowing such bills to go through without a veto, we must take full advantage of our opportunity to improve our fighting position by preparing for a Right-wing primary of the unreliable ally. That means, once initiated, a maximally and total annihilation of electability among the Right. This is a must, if indicated, because you can never keep a Benedict Arnold at the helm of your army – he, too, won many victories and much valor for America before his betrayal made his name synonymous with such, and that is exactly the level of reputational damage I am proposing if we must enact our strategy towards our second preference: victory later.
We should be very selective with items we consider red lines. We can’t honestly to expect to get everything we want in this situation, and, as I said, tax and spending increases are already baked in. I would propose items such as the mutilation of children we just outlawed, the right to homeschool ones children, the protections against DCYF investigations for normal conservative or Christian parenting and education, assaults on the freedoms of speech, religion, and the right to bear arms are the big, bold, bright red lines that must be upheld. And, should that time come when the switch must get flipped from our first preference, victory now, to our second preference, victory later via GOP primary, the switch is immediate, complete, relentless and unapologetic. Total war. After all, these aren’t trifling matters.
Authors’ and Speakers’ opinions are their own and may not represent those of Grok Media, LLC, GraniteGrok.com, its sponsors, readers, authors, or advertisers.
Disagree, agree, Got Something to say? We Want to Hear It. Comment or submit Op-Eds to steve@granitegrok.com