ROPER: What Will Phil Scott Do About the $ 1,700 Federal Tax Credit for K-12 Scholarships?

As BTL readers might remember, the Big Beautiful Bill contained a provision allowing for a $1700 federal tax credit for folks who make a contribution of that amount to any designated Scholarship Granting Organization (SGO) that uses the money to provide children with a variety of educational opportunities. These include scholarships to independent schools, tutoring, educational supplies, technology, transportation, and after-school programs.

It’s up to Governor Scott to decide – by January 1, 2027, which is just a handful of weeks away – if Vermont is going to participate, and, if so, designate one or more SGOs that will receive and dispense the tax-deductible donations. Sooooo… what’s it gonna be, Phil?

This should be a no-brainer. If a state participates, its citizens can contribute to an SGO in their own state and the money will thus be spent on educating their state’s students. Sound thinking. But if a state does not participate, taxpayers who still want the credit (and who wouldn’t) will have to donate to an SGO in some other state and for the benefit of some other state’s students. I mean, what kind of moron would opt for what’s behind door number two here?

More on the morons later, but here’s what’s at stake for Vermont.

The group Education Reform Now estimates that if just 15 to 30 percent of Vermont taxpayers who qualify for the full tax credit amount cash in, it will generate between $56 million and $113 million in scholarship funds to support Vermont kids – that’s if Scott opts to participate. If not, that money flows out of Vermont to… who knows where? Let’s say fundamentalist Baptist schools in Alabama just to fire people up. But probably New Hampshire given they are next door and have based a great part of their economic success on capitalizing on Vermont’s unbroken string of colossally stupid unforced policy errors.

But we have to ask why any politician would ever allow – let alone actively chase away – that level of resources earmarked for helping local children learn? Especially Vermont politicians whose young constituents’ test scores are falling faster than those in any other state and could desperately use the help. And here’s why: because the Democrats are in the pocket of the teachers’ unions, and the NEA would rather see children fail than let even one escape the chains of their greed-driven, tax-dollar-harvesting, modern-day plantations that public schools have devolved into.

So far, three Democrat governors caved to this twisted special interest mindset: Virginia, Oregon, and Minnesota. Fourteen other Democrat governors are still dithering in high population states like California, Illinois, New Jersey, and – really key — fellow New England states Connecticut, Rhode Island, Maine, and Massachusetts. All these far-left governors are under heavy pressure from the adults in the classrooms to royally screw the little people in the classrooms, and if I were a betting person who has accurately gauged the moral character of these folks, I’d put money on a good chunk of them caving to the unions. And here’s what THAT could mean for Vermont.

If just the four Democrat-led New England states opt out, that would free up, again according to Education Reform Now’s estimates, between $1.2 and 2.5 BILLION in tax credit scholarship money that Vermont could compete for. If New Jersey, California, and Illinois opt out, that frees up another $5 to $10 billion we could try to steer to Vermont. Our entire K-12 education budget, bloated as it is, is $2.5 billion. In other words, if we played our cards right, Vermont could use this program to essentially pay for an entirely new k-12 system using out-of-state money – with all the reduced property tax impacts that implies.

We desperately need to reform our education system in Vermont– genuinely reform, as in re-make, not just pour more and more of our hard-earned money down an ossified, union rat hole. The money from this tax credit program could go a long way to providing funding for any number of innovative, outside the box programs our kids need to succeed — provided, of course, that neither the unions nor their allies can control it.

Governor Scott is the only Republican governor in the country who has not signed onto the program. What is he waiting for? If I were him, it would be a number one priority, and I would have my staff working NOW on a marketing program reaching out to taxpayers in the opt-out states to cash in their tax credit with a Vermont SGO. “Keep your money locally here in New England!” Or for the other states, “Send a Thank You to Bernie Sanders!”

If Scott opts in, taxpayers can begin donating to SGOs beginning January 1, and the first scholarship distributions can be expected around the summer of 2027 – so he would have 18 months left in his term to use this program to have a truly meaningful impact on education reform – which he seems to want to be his legacy. Question: Does he have the brains (signing on immediately) and the guts (by which I mean choosing an SGO that he controls outside of the influence of the legislature, which will require some political capital) to seize this very unique opportunity?

Time – and very little of it left – will tell.

Author

  • Rob Roper

    Rob Roper is a freelance writer covering the politics and policy of the Vermont State House. Rob has over twenty years of experience with Vermont politics, serving as president of the Ethan Allen Institute (2012-2022), as a past chairman of the Vermont Republican State Committee, True North Radio/Common Sense Radio on WDEV, as well as working on state statewide political campaigns and with grassroots policy organizations.

    View all posts
Share to...